Arrow icon
Ness Labs: Make the most of your mind
Learn more about Joggo

A Summary of

Why Doesn’t Rationality Seem To Matter?

by
Stephen Pinker
Harvard Gazette
View original

Unfortunately, in an era blessed with unprecedented resources for reasoning, the public sphere is infested with fake news, quack cures, conspiracy theories, and “post-truth” rhetoric.

Human Rationality

  • The cognitive wherewithal to understand the world and bend it to our advantage is the patrimony of our species.
  • For example, the San of the Kalahari Desert in southern Africa owes their survival to a scientific mindset. During a drought, they think ahead to what would happen if they killed the last plant or animal of its kind, and they spare members of the threatened species.
  • Rationality is a kit of cognitive tools that can attain particular goals in particular worlds.
  • When people’s judgments deviate from a normative model, it sometimes reveals a genuine irrationality: The human brain cannot cope with the complexity of a problem, or it is saddled with a bug that cussedly drives it to the wrong answer time and again.
  • But in many cases:
  • A problem may have been presented to them in a deceptive format, and when it is translated into a mind-friendlier guise, they ace it.
  • The normative model may itself be correct only in a particular environment.
  • The model may be designed to bring about a certain goal, however, people are after a different one.
  • Though explanations of irrationality may absolve people of the charge of outright stupidity, to understand is not to forgive.
Related content
See all posts
Arrow icon